Tesla vs. BYD: how to trade the EV stocks

The race for electric vehicle (EV) supremacy is no longer a one-horse race. While Tesla, the charismatic pioneer from Austin, Texas, has long been the face of the EV revolution, a formidable challenger has emerged from the East: BYD, the “Build Your Dreams” powerhouse from Shenzhen, China. For investors, this isn’t just a battle for market share; it’s a clash of ideologies, strategies, and a golden opportunity in the stock market.

This isn’t just about who sells more cars. It’s a fundamental debate on how to win the future of transportation, and your portfolio needs to pay attention.

Tesla (TSLA): the tech disruptor

Tesla is more than a car company; it’s a tech brand that sells a vision. Led by the mercurial Elon Musk, its value is built on:

• Software and ecosystem: Industry-leading autonomous driving software (FSD), a vast Supercharger network, and a loyal brand following.
• Premium branding: Positioned as the Apple of cars—aspirational, sleek, and high-margin.
• Vertical integration: Controls its own software, battery tech (4680 cells), and key components.

BYD (BYDDF): the manufacturing juggernaut

BYD’s strength lies in its breathtaking scale and vertical integration from the ground up. It’s the anti-Tesla in its philosophy:

• The battery behemoth: Originally a battery company, BYD is one of the world’s largest producers of EV batteries, supplying itself and others.
• Cost leadership: Unmatched manufacturing efficiency allows it to produce affordable EVs for the mass market, dominating in China and expanding globally.
• Broad product line: Sells everything from cheap city cars (Seagull) to luxury sedans (Han) and buses.

Tesla vs. BYD: a performance and metrics showdown

Stock performance and market valuation:

• The high-flyer vs. the steady climber: Historically, Tesla (TSLA) has been characterized by its high volatility and explosive growth phases, leading to a premium market capitalization that has often dwarfed traditional automakers. BYD (BYDDF), while also experiencing significant growth, has often seen a less volatile trajectory, reflecting its value and execution-focused profile.
• The valuation gap: A key differentiator is the Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio. Tesla typically commands a significantly higher P/E ratio, indicating that investors are paying more for each dollar of earnings, based on expectations of future hyper-growth. BYD often trades at a more modest P/E, aligning with its value-stock persona and high-volume, lower-margin business model. This gap itself is a key variable for pairs traders to watch.

Operational and delivery metrics:

While stock price is the direct trading instrument, the underlying operational numbers are the engine that drives it.

Tesla vs. BYD: growth vs. value?

• Investing in Tesla is a bet on continued technological dominance and high-profit margins. You’re buying a story of future AI, robotics, and energy storage. However, its valuation is often rich, and it’s highly sensitive to Musk’s announcements and Twitter sentiment.
• Investing in BYD is a bet on manufacturing scale and global mass-market adoption. It’s often seen as a more value-oriented play on the same EV trend, with the backing of Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway. The risks include geopolitical tensions and intense competition in the Chinese market.

Tesla vs. BYD: trading examples

Let’s look at how a trader might approach these two giants differently.

Scenario 1: The earnings play (CFD trading)

• Thesis: Tesla is about to report Q3 earnings. Analysts expect a beat due to strong delivery numbers and new cost-cutting measures.
• Trade: You open a Long (Buy) CFD position on Tesla.
  • You don’t own the stock, but you speculate on its price movement.
  • Entry: $220 per share.
  • Investment: $2,200 (for a 10-share equivalent position).
  • Leverage: 1:5 (Your broker provides 5x exposure, so you only need 20% of the total value as margin).
  • Outcome: Tesla reports stellar earnings and jumps to $250.
  • Profit: (250 – 220) * 10 shares = $300.
  • Without leverage, your $2,200 would have only bought 10 shares, yielding the same $300 profit, but with a much larger capital outlay.

Scenario 2: The pairs trade (relative value)

• Thesis: You believe BYD is undervalued relative to Tesla. While both will rise with the EV tide, you think BYD will outperform Tesla over the next quarter.
• Trade: A pairs trade.
  • Action 1: Go Long on BYD CFD (betting it will go up).
  • Action 2: Go Short on Tesla CFD (betting it will go down or rise slower than BYD).
  • Outcome: Over three months, BYD rises 15% while Tesla rises only 5%.
  • Profit: You profit from the 10% performance difference, hedging you against general market risk in the EV sector.

Scenario 3: The news reactor

• Thesis: The EU announces preliminary tariffs on Chinese EVs. This is seen as a major headwind for BYD’s European expansion.
• Trade: You open a Short (Sell) CFD position on BYD.
  • Entry: $30 per share.
  • Outcome: The news causes a sell-off, and BYD drops to $27.
  • Profit: (30 – 27) * number of shares = You profit from the decline.

Top 5 FX and CFD brokers for stock trading

Navigating the broker landscape is crucial. Here are the top 5 picks from your list, based on regulation, platform strength, fees, and unique selling propositions.

XTB

• Details: A publicly-listed, heavily regulated European broker known for its excellent xStation 5 trading platform.
• Why it’s top 5: Arguably the best-in-class educational resources and market analysis. Commission-free stock CFD trading on real exchange volumes makes it attractive for equity traders. The platform is intuitive yet powerful.
• Best for: Beginner to intermediate traders who value learning and a smooth user experience.

FP Markets

• Details: An Australian-based broker with a strong global reputation, particularly among serious Forex and CFD traders.
• Why it’s top 5: Consistently offers some of the tightest raw ECN spreads in the industry. Excellent execution speeds and deep liquidity. Access to both MetaTrader 4/5 and their own app.
• Best for: Scalpers, high-volume traders, and anyone for whom low trading costs are the number one priority.

BlackBull

• Details: A New Zealand-based broker that has carved a niche by providing truly institutional-grade services to retail and professional traders.
• Why it’s top 5: Prime-of-Prime liquidity, leading to exceptional fill times and deep liquidity. Seamless integration with the MetaTrader 4/5 suite and proprietary tools like BlackBull Trade. Offers social trading via Myfxbook AutoTrade.
• Best for: Professional traders, algorithmic (EA) traders, and funds seeking reliable, high-liquidity execution.

eToro

• Details: A global fintech company that revolutionized trading with its social and copy-trading features.
• Why it’s top 5: Unmatched for its social community. You can copy the trades of successful investors automatically. Offers both CFDs and the ability to buy underlying stocks and crypto assets.
• Best for: New traders who want to learn by copying, and those who enjoy a social, community-driven investment approach.

Risk disclaimer: eToro is a multi-asset platform which offers both investing in stocks and cryptoassets, as well as trading CFDs.

CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 61% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work, and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

This communication is intended for information and educational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice or investment recommendation. Past performance is not an indication of future results.

Copy Trading does not amount to investment advice. The value of your investments may go up or down. Your capital is at risk.

Don’t invest unless you’re prepared to lose all the money you invest. This is a high-risk investment and you should not expect to be protected if something goes wrong. Take 2 mins to learn more.

eToro USA LLC does not offer CFDs and makes no representation and assumes no liability as to the accuracy or completeness of the content of this publication, which has been prepared by our partner utilizing publicly available non-entity specific information about eToro.

AvaTrade

• Details: A well-established, multi-regulated broker known for its user-friendly approach and diverse platform options.
• Why it’s top 5: Offers a huge range of platforms, including MetaTrader 4/5, AvaTradeGO, and even automated trading via DupliTrade and ZuluTrade. Fixed spreads are available, which can appeal to traders who want cost certainty.
• Best for: Traders looking for a trusted, all-in-one broker with multiple strategy options, from manual to fully automated trading.

Related articles:

• Stocks trading and investment for beginners: understanding the market and how it works

• How to start Forex trading: 10 steps to your first deal with a trusted broker

• Best mobile apps for stock trading in 2025: features compared